This actually looks like a great idea.
I mean, it could lead to what you said, but aside from that, and knowing we live at the mercy of /pol/ raids (8ch.pl/leftypol doesn't protect us anymore) it would be really useful.
For every thread ban there is a notification pops up for the board volunteers to take a look at the ban. Then there would be 3 possibilities:
>The ban was because the poster was just fucking up the thread because he was making it difficult to actually have a conversation in the thread because he was being a fucking faggot. With it, that thread ban would be implemented only in that thread specifically. Every thread ban would be implemented temporarily, it would be a time out, from 30 minutes to 1 hour? If it reaches some bizarre proportions, like that poster being autistically dedicated to fuck up that topic, a more severe ban could be implemented.
>The poster was just a /pol/ raider with no actual intention for discussion. In which case, the ban would be implemented into a permanent thread ban until a volunteer reviewed it, and then he would decide. If the ban was unjustified, then the OP would be given a time out of like 6 hours or something like that.
>The OP is a fucking faggot that continues to ban people who actually wants to discuss with him. this can be the case with idpol thread or threads with a /pol/ack OP. With this, the board volunteer would look at it and then would give the respective ban to the retarded OP. This would be easy to see, as these posters would usually just dakka out the reports.
You could notice this to the OP with a grey text at the bottom of his post that says:
By being the OP, you're able to ban people temporarily from your thread if any of these conditions happen.
-The poster is being obnoxious and making discussing a topic difficult
-The poster is a /pol/ack with the objective to make discussion impossible and is chimping out in the thread.
Use your OP powers with responsability, or else...
At the same time, we could gamefy this mechanic of the board. If you're responsible with your thread, and keep it clean of shit lifting, you could get some benefits, be it, I don't know, special flags, special text, maybe a mark that you're a thread moderator (also remarking that you're an oldfag( and stuff like this.
Also, you would be put into a list of waiting for being a board volunteer, so, with it, we would get a pool of people who actively look to keep discussion clean, aren't people which abuse their power, and stuff like that.